Last night, I got my box from BBTS with my two Fistos in it, or rather, my two mailer boxes marked Fisto. One box had a Sorceress in it, as others have been reporting. I e-mailed BBTS right off, and received an e-mail back about half an hour after they opened today. They created a new order for a Fisto to reserve him until the Sorceress arrives back with them (and the order is showing up in my account), had a UPS label sent to me which I alread received and printed out, and told me to return the figure for the exchange with no problems, and an apology, no excuses, even though the mix-up wasn't their fault. Now, I know there's a chance I could get another wrongly packaged Sorceress, not having the figure in hand yet, but I at least have some reason to hope that won't happen. And I was able to do this with one, single e-mail to Big Bad's customer service.
In contrast, I sent a message to Matty through their site to return the two Star sister packs they sent me without being paid for, and was first told they weren't sure what department should handle it and needed more information, then told me how to renew my sub when I did so. Never actually did get an answer on how to simply return the figures.
I've been dealing with Matty so long, I guess I'd forgotten how all this is supposed to work. So glad my new sub is with BBTS...